Victoria A. Selvaggio
  • Home
  • Agent
    • Conferences/Contests/Events
  • Blog - Agenting
  • Contact

Rejections and my response time

9/2/2020

8 Comments

 
​Doing both jobs: writing and agenting, I now know both sides of the desk. I was once a writer who couldn't understand why it took so long (sometimes) to get a response to a submission or how sometimes quick responses were great but not so great.

My first day agenting I received over 400 queries. I was known in the industry but not well-known. By the end of the month, I was into the thousands. Thousands!

New to agenting (there was no QueryManager at that time), I didn't push to "close" to submissions. I know now that I should have. Regardless of that, I am also the type that feels it is respectful to acknowledge (or try to) those who have reached out. Took the time to research me, my interests, and felt we were a fit.

I also know from both sides of the desk how it feels. The quick response. The no response. The vague response. The response that offered great feedback. The response that took a long time to receive.


I also know too, what I do as an agent; I wear many hats. And then, what my tasks consist of with helping maintain a business and agency. Personal life happens, too. Which at times, reading must carry over into that time, because there are only so many hours in a day. 

At every event and interaction I've ever had, I am honest...

My response time isn't the fastest, but I do a lot of tasks (the list is long) and I read everything that comes my way. I take my time. I consider the potential. I research (sometimes) further. I don't spend a minute on a manuscript; I spend what is needed to help make the decision on my end.

I ask for follow ups--welcome polite nudges.

I ask that writers advise when there is interest (agent/editor) and not so much for me to consider the project as well (although, I like to have that opportunity) but to keep me in the loop. Every second counts on my end and I want to be reading manuscripts that are available (not withdrawing manuscripts that aren't available wastes time). 

I ask for writers to withdraw manuscripts--I don't know if something is being revised; I don't know if a writer decided to take a different path. I wish I had physic abilities but I don't. Plus, it's conscientious. Publishing is such a slow process yet, it moves quickly, too. Withdrawing manuscripts, for whatever reason, keeps things efficient and moving forward. 

I ask for writers to reach out (I do receive several emails and inquiries about everything publishing-related and I do my best to help answer them--I remember not knowing much or even what a query was when I first began my publication journey).

So, my point?

I can only work on my end at the speed I can physically and mentally work at. If you have pitched me, I am transparent. It takes me time. I have signed a client before (actually several clients) after interacting for a period of time or even years. But I'm only part of the process. Writers are the other half. 


For the thousands of manuscripts I've received, the % is small on the amount of follow ups, polite nudges, manuscripts being withdrawn, updates about revision or other updates from writers. About 30%.

Only 30%? 


As an agent I know I need to advocate for my clients. But my work isn't the only reason there is success. Clients advocate, too.

Does that mean only 30% of those writers really had complete interest and my name wasn't just another name/just another agent to add to the list?

Possibly.


That makes me sad. 

But this is a reality. Publishing is a business. I get it. 

For me, I know the standards in the industry for response, but they are not my guidelines. I can't guarantee an answer will come a week after you've submitted or 6 weeks.

I can guarantee, though, that if you interest, be in the 30%. Advocate. 

Follow up with me (a lot, if needed).

Also understand that my clients come first. They will be first to mention that I devote my time and energy to every project they share and I help with anything they need.

Understand that I help maintain and run a business/agency. Again, clients can detail this further.
 We're growing. Growth, though, takes time. Our decisions will benefit clients and agents and future clients and agents.

Slow and steady has always been my motto.  

Learn from every experience (good and bad) is another. 


Understand that your submission is important to me. Our interaction might lead to a wonderful partnership. While I am currently closed to submissions, I open for conferences. 

I'm looking for stellar individuals, with awesome creativity.

Individuals who are kind, compassionate, and are understanding of my process--which, is my process. Not another agent's process.

My responses take time and offer feedback. And many writers (those in that percentage) have resubmitted and with those interactions firm relationships are developing.


This post, rather long, is my post and pertains to me and my process. Not another agent or agents.

If an agent has extended an invitation to follow up, do so. If they haven't, don't! Agents are all different in practices. Track that. Have lists. Keep notes in excel.


For me, I'm looking for a partner. One that helps in the process. We will be a team. Working toward the same goal. The author-agent relationship (with me) is never one-sided. It's not that, the moment I receive an individual's submission. Therefore, follow up.

Build that relationship with me.


Some final thoughts, now with knowing both sides of the desk.

I work endless hours and sometimes for free. I don't get paid until I sell a client's book. My first day of agenting was like walking into the library--scaled down, of course to 20 pages each. Exciting and wonderful while also causing a little anxiety.

Rejections in all forms (vague, no response, great feedback, long time to receive) are always welcomed. No matter what, I search for what I can learn from that response. I'm grateful, actually, when an editor apologizes for the length of time and then offers a tidbit of what did not mesh for him/her. Those tidbits, if they come 1 week, 8 weeks, 9 months, 6 months, 1 year later, might just be what that story is missing. What I, as an agent, might have missed. Or possibly, I suggested it and my discussion with my client created a new decision/path for us
to try.

If an editor tells me to follow up, you can bet I do! 

If I have interest in a client's manuscript, I let editors know. They are not on my end, they have no idea who else is considering.

If I have interest and my client wishes to proceed. It's the deal for them (and we've discussed and it's what s/he feels is best), I withdraw the manuscript from editors. I don't like my time being wasted. I don't want to waste theirs. 

If my client wants to make substantial edits, I advise editors further. 


Regardless of the type of rejection and/or length of time for receiving it, I'm always grateful. I understand the process. I know editors are juggling a zillion things. My client's submission isn't the only submission. I am an agent but I'm not the only agent submitting. I also know that I'm building a relationship. That's a goal. Connections are always important. No matter what profession. No matter if representation is offered. No matter if a publication offer happens. 

Part of my agenting job is listening and learning about the editors I'm possibly considering for a project. Yes. Some are slower with response. Some are quick and vague. Some offer great feedback. When I submit to them, I've done my research. I know it might take xyz to receive a response. I have a mental note of that. I don't, though, ever use that in a way that is against my understanding of the process. I'm focused on the "why". Why am I submitting to that editor, knowing I might be waiting? If the fit is a fit, it's a fit.  Also, is that editor an editor that has been in the industry a while. Or just starting out. Workloads do play into responses as well. 

Possibly my next post will get further into this. Dissecting rejections and response time and responses a bit more. They are, after all, tools in this process. 

Bottom line: If you submitted to me and I haven't responded, I am still considering. 

Keep reading. Keep writing. Keep pushing toward your goals.


8 Comments
Jodi Moore link
9/2/2020 09:55:53 am

I hope you realize how much we appreciate your feedback, encouragement and yes, precious TIME. Thank you for giving us a candid glimpse into the world on the other side of the desk, and for all you do for writers and book lovers every day, everywhere.

Reply
Aileen Stewart link
9/2/2020 11:18:34 am

A beautiful explanation of your individual process which has always struck me as very kind and giving. I eagerly await your reopening to submissions as I have been working diligently on perfecting my craft with the help of my CPs and professional critiques I have won.

Hugs,
Aileen

Reply
Robert Budahl
9/2/2020 11:42:14 am

You reviewed my fiction espionage/political thriller and I greatly appreciate the time and attention you gave it. You did not move forward with it and I respect your professional opinion. In fact, I was going to reduce my expectations and just publish it on Amazon or BarnesNoble as an ebook and paperback but I have now decided to go at it all again. The editing, submissions, reviewing the responses, etc. Right now I am caught up in other activities in life so it will be after the first of the year before I begin. I still believe in the potential of publishing "Art of Exploitation: One Step Ahead." I also truly value your view. Thanks for everything Victoria! I know you will continue to succeed.

Best regards,

Robert Budahl

Reply
Stacey Corrigan
9/2/2020 02:47:00 pm

Wow, what great insight. Thanks so much for taking time out of your busy schedule to share with us.

Reply
Annie Lynn link
9/3/2020 11:19:09 pm

Thank you for taking the time to beautifully explain your process, as well as the industry as a whole and what agents are asked to do, or decide to do. I agree about relationships being important first. Take care and keep enjoying what you are doing.

Reply
Judy Bryan link
9/5/2020 07:23:44 am

Thank you for this insightful look into your very busy life. Your thoughtful, compassionate comments show the kind of person you are and the care and dedication you put into your work. Your clients are lucky to have you in their corner!

Reply
Michelle Collins
9/7/2020 12:00:22 pm

Thank you for your insight, update, and motivation! I’m honored to be one of those you’re considering and appreciate all the time you put into fully weighing all the options for each stage of your partnerships. This post is an honest look at your process and I look forward to more of your posts in the future!

Reply
Karin Schott
9/16/2020 07:42:05 am

There are only twenty-four hours in a day. Some part of those days require sleeping and eating. Thank you for explaining the process you engage in as an agent. It was instructive.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.

    Archives

    September 2020

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Website Design by Amstutz Ink